Offers Without Full Disclosure
by Tamsin Caine
You can't tell whether a divorce settlement offer is fair until both of you have fully disclosed your finances – accurate values for all assets, liabilities, incomes and pensions. Without that full picture, the only question you can answer is whether an offer meets your needs, and you risk asking for more than exists or accepting less than is reasonable.
I have had this situation with a number of my clients in the past week. They have received an offer for settlement of the finances but without them having exchanged financial information. We are therefore without full disclosure.
In addition, I have spoken to a couple of people who have been asked by their lawyer what they want in terms of a settlement. Again, in my opinion, until there is full disclosure, we don’t fully understand what there is and may be suggesting more than is available or less that would be reasonable.
What’s the problem?
It might seem on the face of it, that you know whether the offer is a good one or not. However, so that you can truly understand the offer, you need to have the full picture, i.e. an accurate valuation of all the assets of the marriage, the liabilities of the marriage, the income your both receive and the fair value of the pension benefits you each have. Without this information, it is impossible to see whether the offer is fair or not. For example, half a bank account with £10 in it is very different to half a bank account with £1million in it!
The only response you can have, is whether it is enough for your needs, and remember there may not be enough in the pot to satisfy the needs of both of you.
Business Valuations
If one of you owns a business, it is important that the business is valued accurately by an independent valuer. Most couples insist on this when it comes to the residential or commercial property they own, but often fail to value the business. The business does of course provide income to the marriage, and this should be borne in mind, as should the transfer of this income to the spouse retaining the business, if there was previously a shareholding by each party.
Pension Valuations
Just this week, I have come across two clients where their spouses want to keep their pensions out of negotiations and have not properly disclosed their values. As you may have heard me say before, pensions are often the second biggest asset of a marriage and may in some cases be the biggest asset. It is vital that they are not ignored, and the correct valuations are disclosed. From the couple’s perspective, this means ensuring the details are completed fully with CETVs on the form E. It also means that if there are different types of pensions, defined benefit pensions (final salary, career average, etc), or defined contribution pensions with guarantees, that an actuarial report is instructed to ensure that everyone has the full picture. For more information, please refer to the Advice Now Guide https://www.advicenow.org.uk/pensions.
Child Maintenance
If you agree to use the Child Maintenance calculator on the CMS website to work out the amount that should be paid, it is important that the receiving spouse understands the income that this will be based on. For employed spouses, this is relatively straightforward. For those who are directors of limited companies, it is more complex. The salary and dividends will be taken into account. For those who are self employed, we need to understand the net profit of the business.
What do I want?
When we work with clients, we help them to understand what they need from the marital pot to begin their new chapter, move on, and live the life they wish to. We can use specialist software, which enables us to show you how different scenarios and financial settlements might impact your future lifestyle so that you understand the amount that you need. Whilst this can be done without understanding the full value of all the assets, you might not be able to have everything you need if there are not sufficient assets available. Therefore, this needs to be our starting point.
If you feel that we could help you to move forward with sorting out your finances on divorce, please do get in touch or book a meeting using the link https://meetings-eu1.hubspot.com/tamsin-caine/initial-chat-about-how-we-can-help.
Frequently asked questions
Should I accept a divorce settlement offer before financial disclosure?
We would be cautious. To truly understand an offer, you need the full picture: an accurate valuation of all marital assets and liabilities, both incomes and the fair value of each pension. Without that, it is impossible to tell whether the offer is fair – half of a bank account with very little in it is very different from half of one with a large balance. You can only judge whether it meets your needs.
Why shouldn't I tell my lawyer what I want before disclosure?
Until there is full disclosure, you don't fully understand what there is to divide. That means you may suggest more than is actually available, or less than would be reasonable. Remember too that there may not be enough in the pot to meet both people's needs, so understanding the full position is the starting point for working out what you need.
Does a business need to be valued in a divorce?
If one of you owns a business, it is important that it is valued accurately by an independent valuer. Most couples insist on valuing residential or commercial property but often fail to value the business. The business also provides income to the marriage, which should be taken into account – including the transfer of that income to the spouse keeping the business if you both previously held shares.
What if my spouse wants to keep their pension out of the divorce?
Pensions are often the second biggest asset in a marriage and sometimes the biggest, so they shouldn't be ignored and correct values must be disclosed. That means completing Form E fully, including cash equivalent transfer values (CETVs). Where there are defined benefit pensions, such as final salary or career average schemes, or pensions with guarantees, an actuarial report should be instructed so everyone has the full picture.
How is child maintenance worked out for a self-employed or company director ex?
If you agree to use the Child Maintenance Service calculator, the receiving parent needs to understand which income the calculation is based on. For employed parents this is fairly straightforward. For directors of limited companies it is more complex, as both salary and dividends are taken into account. For self-employed parents, you need to understand the net profit of the business.